1.
Influence of water-based exercise on energy intake, appetite, and appetite-related hormones in adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis.
Grigg, MJ, Thake, CD, Allgrove, JE, King, JA, Thackray, AE, Stensel, DJ, Owen, A, Broom, DR
Appetite. 2023;180:106375
-
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
Exercise is an effective way to improve mental and physical health and can influence weight management due to the energy expenditure. Energy balance is influenced by day-to-day variations in energy intake and expenditure. The aim of this study was to address whether water-based exercise influences energy intake, appetite, and appetite related hormones differently to land based exercise in adults. This study is a systematic review and meta-analysis of nine studies which include randomised crossover ( 7 trials), semi-random (1 trial) (water-trial was required prior to iso-energetically matched water trial) and independent group (1 trial) (used in the 12-week study) designs. Results show that post-exercise energy intake is higher after water-based exercise versus a resting control. However, there wasn’t any difference in energy intake when water-based exercise was compared with land-based exercise. Furthermore, when different water temperatures were analysed, post-exercise energy intake was higher in cold water versus neutral water. Additionally, cycling and swimming did not alter fasting plasma concentrations of appetite regulating hormones (ghrelin and leptin), insulin or total peptide YY [gut hormone] but contributed to body mass loss. Authors conclude that if body mass management is a person’s primary focus, it is important to be mindful of the tendency to eat more in the subsequent hours after water-based exercise, as energy intake may be increased when compared to a no exercise control.
Expert Review
Conflicts of interest:
None
Take Home Message:
- The only type of exercise reporting an increase in energy intake was in water-based activities, where the temperature was between 18-20• C. However, this was only when explored in comparison to a resting control. No difference was reported in energy intake when water-based exercise was compared with land-based exercise.
- Any form of exercise, whether land or water-based should be considered where appropriate to reduce the risks of sedentary behaviour.
Evidence Category:
-
X
A: Meta-analyses, position-stands, randomized-controlled trials (RCTs)
-
B: Systematic reviews including RCTs of limited number
-
C: Non-randomized trials, observational studies, narrative reviews
-
D: Case-reports, evidence-based clinical findings
-
E: Opinion piece, other
Summary Review:
Introduction:
Exercise is effective for weight-management alongside other physical and mental health benefits. Changes in appetite-regulating hormones may affect energy balance, e.g. some exercise may suppress appetite, known as exercise-induced anorexia. This review evaluated differences in energy intake, appetite and appetite-related hormones in land-based versus water-based exercise.
Methods:
The meta-analysis followed PRISMA guidelines and was registered on PROSPERO. Literature searching resulted in eight studies published between 1991 and 2021, which met the inclusion criteria (water v control), 5 studies (water v land) and 2 studies (water at different temperatures). Risk of Bias was assessed using Cochrane’s Risk of Bias for randomised trials.
Results:
Data were analysed in RevMan 5.4.1 using fixed effects, generic inverse variance method on energy intake. High heterogeneity prevented analysis on appetite and appetite-related hormones. Standard deviation was inputted based on estimated values for missing data. Heterogeneity was calculated using the I2 index. Sensitivity analyses were conducted. Statistical significance was set at p<0.05 and analyses based on two-tailed Z tests.
All participants had a healthy BMI, were aged 19-39 and ranged from well-trained to non-exercisers. A single bout of water-based exercise increased ad-libitum energy intake compared to a non-exercise control (mean difference [95% CI]: 330 [118, 542] kJ, P = 0.002) but no difference was identified between water and land-based exercise (78 [-176, 334] kJ, P = 0.55). Cold water exercise (18–20 •C) increased energy intake more than neutral water (27–33 •C) temperature (719 [222, 1215] kJ; P < 0.005). One 12-week study reported cycling and swimming did not alter fasting plasma concentrations of total ghrelin, insulin, leptin or total PYY but contributed to body mass loss 87.3 (5.2) to 85.9 (5.0) kg and 88.9 (4.9) to 86.4 (4.5) kg (P < 0.05) respectively.
Conclusion:
Despite limitations, this review may provide preliminary evidence on energy intake and appetite for water-based activities. If weight management is a primary focus, then water temperature needs to be considered, particularly if sub 20•C .
Clinical practice applications:
Although this study suggests cold water exercise may cause an increase in energy intake, 95% confidence intervals for individual studies are very large so results should be interpreted cautiously. Those preferring exercise in cold water, should be encouraged, providing they are mindful of the tendency to eat more post-exercise.
It is not possible to draw any robust conclusions about the ratings of hunger in response to different types of exercise due to limited data. However, according to the review, five studies demonstrated that hunger was suppressed more than control prior at the start of water-based exercise, and during and immediately after exercise.
Considerations for future research:
Most participants were of healthy weight and physically active, however since appetite signals may be dysregulated in obesity, including all weight categories and different activity levels may generate a more comprehensive overview.
Further research recommendations include:
- Measuring the effects of water- based activities on appetite, appetite related hormones and energy intake at different time points following exercise in order to provide recommendations for effective weight management strategies and in a range of different temperatures.
- Using a ‘no exercise’ water immersion control. Evidence suggests that immersion in cold water alone may increase energy expenditure
- Evaluating the effect of a water-based activity, such as swimming performed in a ‘fasted’ and ‘non-fasted’ state to investigate the impact on appetite, appetite related hormones and energy intake.
Abstract
Single bouts of land-based exercise suppress appetite and do not typically alter energy intake in the short-term, whereas it has been suggested that water-based exercise may evoke orexigenic effects. The primary aim was to systematically review the available literature investigating the influence of water-based exercise on energy intake in adults (PROSPERO ID number CRD42022314349). PubMed, Medline, Sport-Discus, Academic Search Complete, CINAHL and Public Health Database were searched for peer-reviewed articles published in English from 1900 to May 2022. Included studies implemented a water-based exercise intervention versus a control or comparator. Risk of bias was assessed using the revised Cochrane 'Risk of bias tool for randomised trials' (RoB 2.0). We identified eight acute (same day) exercise studies which met the inclusion criteria. Meta-analysis was performed using a fixed effects generic inverse variance method on energy intake (8 studies (water versus control), 5 studies (water versus land) and 2 studies (water at two different temperatures)). Appetite and appetite-related hormones are also examined but high heterogeneity did not allow a meta-analysis of these outcome measures. We identified one chronic exercise training study which met the inclusion criteria with findings discussed narratively. Meta-analysis revealed that a single bout of exercise in water increased ad-libitum energy intake compared to a non-exercise control (mean difference [95% CI]: 330 [118, 542] kJ, P = 0.002). No difference in ad libitum energy intake was identified between water and land-based exercise (78 [-176, 334] kJ, P = 0.55). Exercising in cold water (18-20 °C) increased energy intake to a greater extent than neutral water (27-33 °C) temperature (719 [222, 1215] kJ; P < 0.005). The one eligible 12-week study did not assess whether water-based exercise influenced energy intake but did find that cycling and swimming did not alter fasting plasma concentrations of total ghrelin, insulin, leptin or total PYY but contributed to body mass loss 87.3 (5.2) to 85.9 (5.0) kg and 88.9 (4.9) to 86.4 (4.5) kg (P < 0.05) respectively. To conclude, if body mass management is a person's primary focus, they should be mindful of the tendency to eat more in the hours after a water-based exercise session, particularly when the water temperature is cold (18-20 °C).
2.
Prevention of Type 2 Diabetes by Lifestyle Changes: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.
Uusitupa, M, Khan, TA, Viguiliouk, E, Kahleova, H, Rivellese, AA, Hermansen, K, Pfeiffer, A, Thanopoulou, A, Salas-Salvadó, J, Schwab, U, et al
Nutrients. 2019;11(11)
-
-
-
Free full text
Plain language summary
With Type 2 Diabetes growing globally this paper analyses whether T2D is preventable with lifestyle measures including diet. Seven RCTs were included for review with a total of 4090 participants, and 2466 incidents of T2D, and were chosen on the basis that the lifestyle interventions included both physical exercise and diet (typically Mediterranean Diet). They found that diet and lifestyle intervention reduced the risk of T2D by 47%. Sustained risk reduction was also found in follow-up studies up to 10 years later with participants maintaining improved blood glucose control. Lifestyle interventions may also reduce risk factors for cardiovascular disease. Weight reduction was considered a cornerstone of preventing T2D and adherence to lifestyle changes a key element in long term prevention. Dietary foods reviewed include processed meats, white rice and sugars which correlated highly with T2D whilst leafy greens, berries, wholegrains, legumes, dietary fibre and yoghurt correlate with a lower risk of T2D. Dietary patterns of skipping breakfast and snacking correlate higher with T2D. Different criteria for evaluating physical activity estimate that it reduces risk factors by 50%. In conclusion there is high evidence that lifestyle factors which optimise diet, increase physical activity and promote weight reduction are preventative factors for T2D and can be sustained long term.
Abstract
Prevention of type 2 diabetes (T2D) is a great challenge worldwide. The aim of this evidence synthesis was to summarize the available evidence in order to update the European Association for the Study of Diabetes (EASD) clinical practice guidelines for nutrition therapy. We conducted a systematic review and, where appropriate, meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials (RCTs) carried out in people with impaired glucose tolerance (IGT) (six studies) or dysmetabolism (one study) to answer the following questions: What is the evidence that T2D is preventable by lifestyle changes? What is the optimal diet (with a particular focus on diet quality) for prevention, and does the prevention of T2D result in a lower risk of late complications of T2D? The Grading of Recommendations Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) approach was applied to assess the certainty of the trial evidence. Altogether seven RCTs (N = 4090) fulfilled the eligibility criteria and were included in the meta-analysis. The diagnosis of incident diabetes was based on an oral glucose tolerance test (OGTT). The overall risk reduction of T2D by the lifestyle interventions was 0.53 (95% CI 0.41; 0.67). Most of the trials aimed to reduce weight, increase physical activity, and apply a diet relatively low in saturated fat and high in fiber. The PREDIMED trial that did not meet eligibility criteria for inclusion in the meta-analysis was used in the final assessment of diet quality. We conclude that T2D is preventable by changing lifestyle and the risk reduction is sustained for many years after the active intervention (high certainty of evidence). Healthy dietary changes based on the current recommendations and the Mediterranean dietary pattern can be recommended for the long-term prevention of diabetes. There is limited or insufficient data to show that prevention of T2D by lifestyle changes results in a lower risk of cardiovascular and microvascular complications.
3.
Effect of Vitamin D Supplementation on Obesity-Induced Insulin Resistance: A Double-Blind, Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Trial.
Cefalo, CMA, Conte, C, Sorice, GP, Moffa, S, Sun, VA, Cinti, F, Salomone, E, Muscogiuri, G, Brocchi, AAG, Pontecorvi, A, et al
Obesity (Silver Spring, Md.). 2018;26(4):651-657
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Vitamin D concentration has been inversely associated with impaired glucose regulation, insulin resistance and risk of metabolic dysfunction. The aim of the study was to evaluate whether Vitamin D supplementation could improve insulin sensitivity in patients with a high risk of diabetes. The study is a randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial. The participants with obesity were supplemented with Vitamin D or placebo on top of a hypocaloric diet. Results indicate that Vitamin D supplementation combined with weight loss is linked with a significant improvement in insulin sensitivity in vitamin D deficient participants with obesity.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE The aim was to investigate whether vitamin D supplementation, combined with a hypocaloric diet, could have an independent effect on insulin sensitivity in subjects with both overweight and hypovitaminosis D. Changes from baseline in anthropometric parameters, body composition, glucose tolerance, and insulin secretion were considered as secondary outcomes. METHODS Eighteen volunteers who were nondiabetic and vitamin D deficient and had BMI > 25 kg/m2 were randomized (1:1) in a double-blind manner to a hypocaloric diet + either oral cholecalciferol at 25,000 IU/wk or placebo for 3 months. Hyperinsulinemic-euglycemic clamp to measure insulin sensitivity was performed at baseline and after intervention. RESULTS Body weight in both groups decreased significantly (-7.5% in the vitamin D group and -10% in the placebo group; P < 0.05 for both), with no between-group differences. Serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D levels in the vitamin D group increased considerably (from 36.7 ± 13.2 nmol/L to 74.8 ± 18.7 nmol/L; P < 0.001). Insulin sensitivity in the vitamin D group improved (from 4.6 ± 2.0 to 6.9 ± 3.3 mg·kg-1 ·min-1 ; P < 0.001), whereas no changes were observed in the placebo group (from 4.9 ± 1.1 to 5.1 ± 0.3 mg·kg-1 ·min-1 ; P = 0.84). CONCLUSIONS Cholecalciferol supplementation, combined with a weight loss program, significantly improves insulin sensitivity in healthy subjects with obesity and might represent a personalized approach for insulin-resistant subjects with obesity.
4.
Nutrition, Health, and Regulatory Aspects of Digestible Maltodextrins.
Hofman, DL, van Buul, VJ, Brouns, FJ
Critical reviews in food science and nutrition. 2016;56(12):2091-100
-
-
-
Free full text
-
Plain language summary
Maltodextrin (MD), a type of refined carbohydrate, is made up of chains of glucose molecules but yet has little sweetness. It is derived from crops rich in starch via industrial processing and is widely used in the food industry. Glucose from digested maltodextrins is rapidly absorbed in the gut. Research demonstrated that consumption of other types of refined carbohydrates, strongly impact blood glucose levels, insulin, and fat metabolism and can contribute to obesity. Due to the health concerns associated with high consumption of refined carbohydrates, this article tried to establish if a similar concern could be associated with MD. Reviewed were current knowledge about digestible MD, their production, digestion, absorption, metabolism and potential effects on health, their use in food technology with a note on regulatory aspects in the EU and US. Even though increased refined carbohydrate consumption is linked to increased health risks, negative effects of MDs consumption have not been reported. As MD’s are preferable to glucose, they can be useful in selected circumstances like in the application for sports drinks. However, due to a lack of data the authors raise caution against excessive intake of MD’s and encourage to take into consideration the specific health context.
Abstract
Digestible maltodextrins are low-sweet saccharide polymers consisting of D-glucose units linked primarily linearly with alpha-1,4 bonds, but can also have a branched structure through alpha-1,6 bonds. Often, maltodextrins are classified by the amount of reducing sugars present relative to the total carbohydrate content; between 3 and 20 percent in the case of digestible maltodextrins. These relatively small polymers are used as food ingredients derived by hydrolysis from crops naturally rich in starch. Through advances in production technology, the application possibilities in food products have improved during the last 20 years. However, since glucose from digested maltodextrins is rapidly absorbed in the small intestine, the increased use has raised questions about potential effects on metabolism and health. Therefore, up-to-date knowledge concerning production, digestion, absorption, and metabolism of maltodextrins, including potential effects on health, were reviewed. Exchanging unprocessed starch with maltodextrins may lead to an increased glycemic load and therefore post meal glycaemia, which are viewed as less desirable for health. Apart from beneficial food technological properties, its use should accordingly also be viewed in light of this. Finally, this review reflects on regulatory aspects, which differ significantly in Europe and the United States, and, therefore, have implications for communication and marketing.